I received a Nook Simple Touch™ from a good friend last Christmas and love it. My friend chose Nook for both of us over the then-current Kindle offering because of the OverDrive® library compatibility. The OverDrive service allows participating public libraries to “lend” out digital versions of books to Nook and other tablet owners as if they were hardcopy books. You just need to get yourself a library card from a participating library. Thousands of libraries around the country are part of the OverDrive service which made Nook stand out from Kindle – a year ago.
In September 2011, Amazon and OverDrive announced their new alliance to allow the Kindle to participate in the OverDrive service and accept downloaded public library eBooks. Kindle Fire is also offering an owner lending library (Nook has the LendMe™ program), which was another reason my friend went with Barnes & Noble at the time.
Both the Nook Tablet and Kindle Fire can accept OverDrive downloads as well as offer a lending library for its respective owners. Other similarities include:
- Full color, 7″ touch screen display
- Integrated 802.11b/g/n Wi-Fi
- Dual processor hardware; Android-ish OS
- USB port for external downloads
- Availability of over one million books, games, apps, movies, TV shows and song titles
- Netflix, HuluPlus and Pandora apps built in
- Web browsing and email apps built-in
- Children’s Books and Graphic Novels
- Built-in dictionary while reading
- Cloud storage, limited to purchased content native to B&N/Amazon, respectively.
After exhaustive research among customer reviews and articles by “experts”, I have come to some conclusions based solely on my own personal taste. In many respects, the Nook Tablet and Kindle Fire are similar devices, but a few features set the Nook Tablet apart from the Kindle Fire, in my estimation.
- BATTERY LIFE. Both devices were tested under ideal conditions (Wi-Fi off, power save mode) and the NT battery will give you about 3 hours more reading time or 1.5 hours more video time than KF.
- RESPONSIVENESS. Both devices boast a dual processor and run on proprietary variants of the Android OS, but anecdotal data claims that NT offers the better response times during scrolling, page turning, etc. KF only beat NT on Web page downloads – 2.5 sec on KF vs. 4 sec on NT.
- READING FEATURES. NT still wins in best text display – easy on the eyes, display of page numbers, readable in sunlight, easy bookmarking management and font flexibility.
- SOCIAL MEDIA ACCESS. NT will link to your Facebook and Twitter accounts so you can post comments on media that you have read, viewed or listened to.
- LOCAL STORAGE. KF includes 8GB local storage, but about 2GB are sucked up by the OS and its apps. That leaves about 6GB for storing user content and no expansion is available because no SD port is available on KF. The NT has 13GB of available local storage, 12GB reserved for B&N content. However, the NT sports a microSD slot and will support up to a 32GB microSD card, expanding non-B&N storage far more than the KF.
- NON-AMAZON MUSIC FILES. KF will only support Amazon formatted and MP3 music files, ruling out many iTunes and all *.WAV files. If you can successfully convert *WAV files to MP3 without sacrificing sound quality, maybe the KF will work for you. NT will support almost any music file format.
- ERGONOMICS. The NT just looks more attractive than the KF. Menus fit better on the NT screen, pages turn smoother, colors and text are more clear and crisp and reading in sunlight is still better on the Nook product. The NT boasts a Home key and a physical volume control button; the KF has neither. The NT is about ½ ounce lighter than the KF, making it easier to read with one hand.
- BUILT-IN MICROPHONE. The NT allows you to narrate certain children’s books so your kids or grand kids can hear a story in your voice.
- PRICE. NT was introduced at $249, the KF at $199.
Two of KF’s features – Instant Streaming Videos (Amazon hosted content) and WhisperSync (synching video playback to TV or PC) require Amazon Prime membership. It costs $79 per year and was first introduced to discount shipping on selected Amazon products for its members. B&N does not require any membership for its Nook services.
Aside from the Web page loading, I found one flaw with the NT: the speaker port is on the back of the device. If you lean the NT face up on any surface while playing music or video, the audio may sound a bit muffled. Since audio is not an important application for me, this flaw has no weight for me.
If you want to save the $50, consider the Nook Color™. B&N dropped the price on the Nook Color to $199 with the promise to add streaming Netflix, HuluPlus and Pandora services and comic books “soon”. It has all the readability features, Wi-Fi and most of the ergonomic characteristics of the NT at the KF price. But for my money, I’d go with the Nook Tablet.
Selected Sources: Customer Reviews, Amazon.com
Customer Reviews, Barnes & Noble
Lean Mean Consuming Machine, by Casey Johnston
CNET Review, “Kindle Fire vs. Nook Tablet” by David Carnoy and Donald Bell